Can Fregeans have 'I'-thoughts?

Abstract : We examine how Frege's contrast between identity judgments of the forms " a=a " vs. " a=b " would fare in the special case where 'a' and 'b' are complex mental representations, and 'a' stands for an introspected 'I'-thought. We first argue that the Fregean treatment of I-thoughts entails that they are what we call " one-shot thoughts " : they can only be thought once. This has the surprising consequence that no instance of the " a=a " form of judgment in this specific case comes out true, let alone a priori true. This further reinforces Glezakos's objections against the setup of Frege's puzzle, while also raising what we think is an acute problem for Fregeans, insofar as I-thought (and indexical thinking more generally), understood in their way, turns out to be incompatible with some basic features of rationality.
Type de document :
Article dans une revue
Revista de Filosofía de la Universidad de Costa Rica, Luis Diego Cascante, 2014, Gottlob Frege’s Puzzle. A reexamination of the Cognitive Significance Phenomenon, LIII (136), pp.97-105. 〈http://revistas.ucr.ac.cr/index.php/filosofia〉
Liste complète des métadonnées

Littérature citée [13 références]  Voir  Masquer  Télécharger

https://jeannicod.ccsd.cnrs.fr/ijn_01138873
Contributeur : Marie Guillot <>
Soumis le : jeudi 2 avril 2015 - 21:06:55
Dernière modification le : jeudi 11 janvier 2018 - 06:20:28
Document(s) archivé(s) le : mardi 18 avril 2017 - 09:45:22

Fichier

Billon Guillot 2014 - Can Freg...
Fichiers éditeurs autorisés sur une archive ouverte

Identifiants

  • HAL Id : ijn_01138873, version 1

Collections

Citation

Alexandre Billon, Marie Guillot. Can Fregeans have 'I'-thoughts?. Revista de Filosofía de la Universidad de Costa Rica, Luis Diego Cascante, 2014, Gottlob Frege’s Puzzle. A reexamination of the Cognitive Significance Phenomenon, LIII (136), pp.97-105. 〈http://revistas.ucr.ac.cr/index.php/filosofia〉. 〈ijn_01138873〉

Partager

Métriques

Consultations de la notice

332

Téléchargements de fichiers

414